“But We Love Martha Jones!” – The Doctor Who Fandom’s Selective Memory of Racism
Be aware that this article contains explicit examples of anti-black racism and misogynoir.
**Contents**
Intro
1. Everybody Hates Martha
2. Utopia-ish
3. Martha vs Bill
4. Martha Triumphant?Intro
To say being a Martha Jones fan from 2007-2017 was hard would be an understatement. The fandom claimed she was too clingy. Too jealous of Rose. Too bitter. Too bad a companion. For as long as I can remember, Martha Jones wasn’t just an unpopular companion – she was THE unpopular companion. So this recent increase in “my issues with [insert companion of colour here] isn’t about race. Everybody loved Martha Jones!” has me raising an eyebrow. Freema Agyeman as part of Ofcom’s Diversity In Broadcasting Event answered a question on her time as Doctor Who’s first Black companion. She describes her time as “good and bad”. She handled the criticism of Martha as a character “but the racism… yeah, yeah couldn’t rationalise that” as she pauses in the video. In the silence we get a clear answer – Freema Agyeman did not have an easy time as Doctor Who’s first Black companion. So when I see comments about how much she was loved, or how no one knew what Freema was going through when speaking out about the racism she experienced, or “My sus posts about Ryan & Yaz aren’t racist! I loved Martha!” I, and many other Black/mixed Black fans and other fans of colour have bad tastes in our mouths. We remember the real history of how Martha Jones was treated – and her history wasn’t a kind one.
one hundred percent correct, I was on LiveJournal in 2007 and Martha was hated before she was even on the show. I remember when the first pictures of her came out someone said she looked like a “chavvy whore” and that comment made it to LJ icons and the like. And as soon as someone created a Martha fan community, lifeonmartha, someone else made a comm called strifeonmartha to make fun of her and her fans. BEFORE SHE HAD BEEN INTRODUCED. (Life on Martha is actually still there!)
Martha hate lasted well into the Tumblr era of fandom and I can’t believe people are denying it now.