call the midwife

In case you’re wondering how CTM’s ‘ship woman’ story actually transpired in reality, Jenny Worth describes it like this (cut for disturbing content, though you can probably tell from the tags how this is gonna go:)

In the memoir it’s Chummy, not Trixie, who attends to the birth aboard the ship. There, Kirsten (referred to mostly as Kirsty in the book) tells Chummy that her father started prostituting her when she was fourteen, and he rapes her too. She doesn’t find anything horrifying about the situation, thinks the incest is perfectly normal, and loves her father for taking care of her even as she’s…fucking…raped by ten or twelve men a night. The baby is born and Chummy plans to go back later for the post-natal care (very important), but the harbourmaster tells the nuns the ship sailed away in the night, the captain obviously having twigged that medical professionals wouldn’t let “raped your daughter constantly since she was a teenager” go.

MIGHT have to face a prison sentence?!!?!

Anyway, out of all the horrible stories in CTM the memoir, that one sticks in my mind the most. These days surely, surely something would be done, but it wasn’t these days, so that poor woman just sailed out of history and might well have died.

taiey
replied to your post “Call the Midwife is still the only show I’ve ever seen do an incest…”

How’d thy do it?

Basically Jenny (the main character) is assigned to nurse a elderly man dying of cancer and notes how close he and his sister are, and then realises that the siblings share a bed as well. (Whether or not they did anything more than just sleep in the bed is never said.) Jenny tells the head nun this, in horror, but the nun tells her that both siblings grew up in the workhouses, which were segregated by gender, and by the time they got out they had both been separately abused so horribly that “family meant nothing to them anymore” (paraphrased). Plus, well, they’re old and don’t have children from each other or anyone else, so no-one’s really being hurt. The old man dies of cancer and when Jenny comes back the next day she finds his sister has killed herself too, because due to the circumstances of her childhood she simply had no way of supporting herself once her only support was gone.

It’s sort-of based on a true story which Jenny Worth wrote about in her book Shadows of the Workhouse, but I’ve never been able to work out how she could have possibly known for certain the exact nature of these people’s relationship (there’s a passage detailing the brother’s sexual feelings towards his sister, which… like, Worth couldn’t have known their thoughts) so take that with a pinch of salt I guess.

Call the Midwife goes very hard on how appallingly bad the workhouses were.

Call the Midwife is still the only show I’ve ever seen do an incest story… right, for lack of a better word. Probably because it actually had a point, namely “If the least bad thing to happen in the workhouses was a brother and sister committing (probably non-consummated) incest, how could we as a society have allowed such inhumane treatment to have happened for so long?”

(That and it was based on a true story. Although, with no disrespect meant to the late Jenny Worth, I really think she probably fudged or embellished some of the details.)