Harry Potter fic: The Prophecy
Title: The Prophecy
Author:
Rating: PG13
Characters: Petunia, Vernon, Lily, James
Summary: As her newborn baby lies close to death, Petunia Dursley is visited by her sister.
The Prophecy
“She’s here,” Venon said.
Petunia shifted her bleary eyes from the wall-mounted television, and looked at her husband. “Who’s here?”
“Her,” said Venon. “Her and him.”
Petunia followed his line of sight. She saw James Potter first, examining a map on the wall, poking it to try and make it move. And then, much nearer- Lily, speaking to an orderly. Her sister seemed perfectly calm, but Petunia could even now read her like a book. She was frantic.
“Go out there and tell her where we are,” she said to Vernon. He hesitated. “Go on!” she said.
Venon trudged out into the corridor. He approached Lily, and tapped her on the shoulder- the first time, Petunia noted, that they had ever touched. Very few words seemed to be exchanged, but within seconds, all three of them were at her door.
“Tuney,” Lily said. “Are you all right?”
Petunia didn’t look at her. “It’s a boy,” she said. “He’s still in intensive care. You can’t see him.”
“We didn’t come here to see him, we came to see you,” Lily said. She raised her hand to her heavily pregnant belly- and then hastily removed it again. “Tuney…”
“Petunia,” Petunia corrected her, a cold snap to her voice. “You can go, Lily. This isn’t your sort of place.” She let the bitterness drip out of her voice.
“C’mon, Lil,” James said, putting his hand on her shoulder. “You came to see if she was okay and she is.”
Lily swallowed and turned her back. James glared- not at Petunia herself, or even Vernon- just around the cold little room, as if in disgust at its primitivism. Lily stepped out into the corridor-
“Wait,” Vernon croaked.
In shock, Lily turned. Petunia and James stared, both shaken to the core- Venon was almost crying.
“Can you fix this?” he demanded, flinging his large arm in a gesture to the hospital in general. “Can…you…fix…our boy?”
Before Lily even began to speak, James shook his head- something only Petunia saw.
“I don’t know,” Lily said, blinking. “There are certain charms they use at St Mungo’s, but…”
“Tell me straight, girl!” Vernon roared. “Can you help him?”
“No,” James said, stepping in front of his girlfriend. “I’m sorry. We’re sorry.” He closed the door behind him, drowning out the sounds of the hospital halls. “It’s really dangerous, performing spells on sick Muggles-”
“Sick Muggles?” Petunia shouted from her bed, every inch of her hurting. “Sick Muggles? That’s my child that you’re talking about! My baby!”
“Sorry,” James said quickly. “I mean…there’s nothing we can do, too much might go wrong. We’re not exactly Healers- doctors. And it’s against the law-”
“AGAINST THE LAW?” Vernon roared. “It’s AGAINST THE LAW to save our child? It’s AGAINST THE LAW to-”
“No,” Lily interrupted, sounding tearful. “I mean, not quite. But…the doctors here are all working for him, they’re going to save him, we can’t intervene with Muggle medicine.”
Vernon just spluttered, and stared around the room- Petunia knew he was looking for something to lash out at. She also knew that he would never hit a woman, let alone a pregnant one- her sister was safe from her husband. But James had placed Lily firmly behind him, and opened the door.
“We’re sorry, honestly,” he said, leading Lily out into the corridor. “We won’t disturb you anymore.” He appeared to want to say something else, but it never came.
He lead Lily away and within an instant they were gone. Venon flung open the door and glared after them- he seemed to be gearing up to shout, but didn’t. He slammed the door and turned back to Petunia. She was crying. He went and put an arm around her-
“Fifty percent,” Petunia sobbed. “Fifty percent chance he’ll live. We don’t even have a name for him yet.”
Vernon gave a grunt- only Petunia, out of all the people in the world, knew he was close once more to tears.
“It’s okay,” she told him, after a while. “Go and get yourself a cup of tea.”
Her husband nodded- he seemed to have slid into a grief-induced stupor. “I’ll get something for you too,” he said, reaching into his pocket for some change. “I’ll get you…Victoria sponge?”
“Yes please.”
He kissed her on the cheek and went out. He seemed to have aged several years in the past few years- he walked with the tread of someone much older. Petunia huddled under the bedcovers, praying things would return to normal, praying she would return home with a healthy baby in her hands-
After a few minutes, the door opened, and she turned around expecting to see Vernon with cake. But it wasn’t him- it was Lily.
“Go away,” Petunia told her sister. “We’ve said all there is to say.”
“James has contacted the Ministry of Magic,” Lily said, crossing the room to her. “They said…um…”
“Tell me!”
“They said there’s a possibility they could send someone down from St Mungo’s,” Lily said quietly. “Because…because magic runs in our family now.”
Petunia’s stomach clenched. “You mean…”
“Because there’s a chance he’s got magical blood.”
There was a choking noise from behind them. Both women turned to see Vernon there, the Victoria Sponge quivering in his hands. “You…” he spluttered. “You can’t mean…” He slammed the door. “You can’t tell me MY SON…”
“It’s possible,” Lily said. “Vernon…”
“No,” Vernon said. He bashed the plates of cake and tea down onto a table. “A possibility! A possibility! No interfering with us Muggles…unless he’s actually one of your kind! Then you’ll look into it! THEN!”
Petunia thought of her husband raising a wizard child. She felt sick at the thought. “Dear…”
“Us Muggles just not good enough, eh?” Vernon spat, ignoring her and focusing on Lily. “Can’t wave a magic wand, better off dead? Isn’t that right, girl?”
“I’d do anything, if I could!” Lily said, almost crying. “I have a child due myself! But if I do anything, if James does anything, it’ll almost certainly make things worse! And there are people helping you, people who know what they’re doing-”
“GET OUT!” Vernon roared. “You little freak, get out!”
Lily’s face rendered both sympathy and anger as she turned to her sister. “Me and James will always be nearby. We always have been-”
“You’ve been stalking us?” Vernon spat.
“No, we’ve been protecting you,” Lily shot back. “But you don’t notice, do you? There’s terrible things out there in the world and I don’t want them to get to you.” She took a deep breath. “We’ll continue to protect you. You’re my sister, Petunia. Alright?”
She turned on her heel and left. The Dursleys remained alone, not speaking, for a long while. Finally, Petunia managed to say it.
“Would you reject our son, if he was a wizard? Give him up? Tell me you wouldn’t. I wouldn’t. Please.”
Vernon grunted once more. And made her wait a few seconds for the answer. “He wouldn’t be able to help it, if…if he was like that,” he finally said. “Wouldn’t be our fault. Be hers…we’d just, we’d just not tell anyone. Send him to normal school. Get…some of those people to teach him how to control it. Maybe. We’d get by.”
Petunia nodded, and gave him a one-armed hug from where she sat. “And…darling…you’d love him?”
“Yes,” Vernon said. He sounded amazed that she’d had to ask…and she was more relieved than she had ever been. “‘Course. He’s my son! My blood! Our blood.”
Petunia felt dizzy. But the sickness had gone. “Thanks,” she whispered to him.
“Have some cake,” Vernon told her.
*
It seemed to take so long, so long, so many days of waiting-
“He’s out of the woods,” the doctor told them. “You can see him.”
They sat with their baby for a very long time, observing his tiny size. Vernon made a point of shaking the hand of every doctor.
“Someone made an effort,” he murmured, in a haze of relief. “Someone…”
Petunia knew that Lily would be around- knew she wouldn’t leave- and she was right. Two days after the all-clear, when Vernon had gone home to collect the mail, Lily appeared.
“He’s beautiful,” she said to Petunia. “Tuney…I want our children to be friends.”
“You didn’t lift a finger to help him, when he was dying.”
“I lifted a finger. Others didn’t.” Lily’s face became hard. “I’ve done a lot for you! Don’t you realise, you’re a target?”
Petunia said nothing. Lily just sighed.
“What’s his name?”
“We haven’t chosen one yet.”
Lily nodded. “Tuney…Petunia…this is important. Just one more question and then I can leave you alone forever if you want. What was your baby’s original due date?”
“The thirty-first of July,” Petunia said, puzzled by the intense look in her sister’s eyes. “Why?”
“I hope I don’t have to tell you,” Lily said. “Just trust me. Please, trust me.”
Petunia looked down at her baby, and then back to her sister. Her sister with her huge pregnant belly, about to bring another wizard into the world…”Don’t leave me alone forever,” she told Lily. “I don’t want you here, any more than you want to be here. Every choice you’ve ever made, I’ve hated. But…” She swallowed. “Maybe our children can be friends.”
“I hope so,” Lily said. She looked down at the baby and left the room, quietly, running a hand over her sister’s shoulders.
Petunia remained where she was- but when a nurse entered the room and advised her to take a break, she did. She followed the way Lily had gone, down the corridors, until she saw a flash of red hair-
Both Lily and James stood near the hospital entrance, in deep conversation. She went closer, made herself unobtrusive (a talent she had practised all her childhood) and listened.
They were speaking of a prophecy.
“It could never have been him,” James said to Lily gently. “To those who have thrice defied him…remember?”
“Of course I remember,” Lily snapped. “Of course I remember, every damn day! But they have thrice defied him, just by staying alive. We prevented three attacks on them, exactly three!”
“But the kid’s not a wizard. Or born on the right day. Maybe he would have been…but he wasn’t.”
“I know! But, the power the Dark Lord knows not. That’s…James, Muggles have power! More than you’ve ever realised. What if…James, it could still be him. Not our baby. Her baby.”
“It can’t be.”
“I know. But I thought…I hoped…think of how much easier it would have been!” Lily was crying. “If it was her child and not mine. I know how bad that sounds, I know how bad that is! Dooming your sister’s child, to save your own. But…”
She started sobbing, and James held her tight. Petunia continued to watch unnoticed, feeling more betrayed than she had ever felt in her entire life.
“It’s not that bad, Lily, you’re not a bad person,” James told her, still hugging her. “It would have worked out better, if it had been her kid. I mean, he’s not on the radar of You-Know-Who, not like we are. We could’ve protected him. We would have. He wouldn’t be doomed…our baby won’t be doomed, either.”
Lily nodded sadly.
“It’s alright,” James said. “S’better for them, not having any more magic around. S’much better for them, that their kid’s a dud…”
They started to walk away. Lily said something, but Petunia didn’t hear it. She turned away and returned to her hospital room, and waited there until her husband returned. Eventually, later than she would have liked, he did.
“How’s the boy?” was the first thing Vernon asked.
“He’s doing fine,” Petunia answered. “Better than they even expected…he’s a fighter, they say.”
Vernon puffed his chest out. “And no more visits from you-know-who?”
Internally, Petunia flinched. But she kept up her smile nonetheless. “No. I think they’ve gone home.”
“Good,” Vernon said. He sat down on the nearest chair. “Thought up any names yet?”
“I think I quite like ‘Dudley,'” said Petunia carefully.
Vernon thought it over. “Good…good strong name! I like it.” He shifted his chair right over to her, and kissed her. Petunia kissed back, almost happy, almost.
“I’m so glad he’s not…one of them,” she said.
“As am I,” Vernon said proudly. “Nice, normal, healthy lad!”
Petunia thought of her child and Lily’s growing up together, being friends. And then she thought of what the alternative could have been- her child dying, and her sister’s child living. “Mmmm.”
“What’s wrong?” Vernon asked.
“Nothing,” Petunia said. “Just thinking about my sister and her stupid freak society.” She pushed away the anger and guilt, and thought instead of her new baby -the boy who lived. “So cruel and arrogant, thinking everyone ought to be like them. Well, I’m proud to say we’re perfectly normal, thank you very much.”
“We’ll stick together, love,” Vernon told her. “We’ll make it through.”
July 4, 2012 @ 5:47 pm
Great story. I love how it gives some depth and reason behind the Dursley’s hatred of magic and even to their excessive spoiling of Dudley. Nice to see some motivation to the Dursleys.
July 4, 2012 @ 10:15 pm
Thank you! I like to think it gives an explanation for that, even though they did raise Dudley appallingly… I always thought there was more to the Dursleys. Especially Petunia. :)
July 4, 2012 @ 9:11 pm
Yes–this makes so much sense. Made me understand the Durnsleys.
July 4, 2012 @ 10:15 pm
Thank you! :D
July 5, 2012 @ 3:49 am
I love every bit of this. It’s a very thoughtful, thorough exploration of the Dursley-Potter dynamics and I commend you for it. Not many writers look this fairly upon Vernon and Petunia, so it’s always a refreshing treat to find a piece which presents them as human beings rather than monstrous caricatures but this – such a well balanced and multi-layered image of them – is well above the bar. It fills me with the fuzzies just to bask in its existence. Your Vernon is so perfect! He’s just the right measure of gentleman-battle-axe. He’ll holler and condemn but he’s not going to lay his hands on a woman and when the tumult is finished, he’s eager to move on and push the unpleasantness aside. Here is a man who will stand in loving devotion to his family (as defined by him), which is a trait often passed over due to his treatment of Harry. I liked the whole exchange with of course I’d love my…er…’that’…son! It’s very clear that simple oddness is not the issue he has with them – his terming of Lily as a ‘freak’ was so aptly timed that it gives a new light to the insult, with the freakishness being more about their social behaviour and not the magic they were born with. Petunia of course was lovely. It was nice to see her at this stage in her life, between nursing childhood ill-wills and developing an adult’s bitter, secretly mournful loathing. The quick resolve that she wouldn’t, steadfastly, absolutely would not let go of her son if he had magic rings perfectly true while also reflecting what the depths of her issues with magical people really are. Similar to her husband, Petunia’s greatest source of revulsion with the Wizarding lifestyle has always been that it excludes her, something she would have more control over concerning her own son. And her desire for peace with her sister and future nephew, the decision to be magnanimous, made Lily’s betrayal so much worse. Dudley being named for his ‘dud’ quality hurt and fit in all the best ways. I can see how this start in life led to him not only being spoiled but being fattened up as much as Petunia could manage in the beginning. Dursleys and Potters aside, I also really appreciate having the Muggle/Wizard divide illustrated so well. The Wizarding World does hold itself above and apart from Muggles to such an extent that the lines connecting them can’t always be seen. I liked Lily’s struggle to convince James that Muggles have power – are actually capable of things, believe it or not – and his apparent inability (as someone born and raised in the Wizarding World) to see them as even being close to equals. Thank you so much for sharing this! It’s all just wonderful beyond reason. <3
July 5, 2012 @ 5:54 pm
such a well balanced and multi-layered image of them – is well above the bar. It fills me with the fuzzies just to bask in its existence. If I could, I would run around the room going ‘EEEEEEEE!’ at this. <3 Your Vernon is so perfect! He’s just the right measure of gentleman-battle-axe. He’ll holler and condemn but he’s not going to lay his hands on a woman and when the tumult is finished, he’s eager to move on and push the unpleasantness aside Vernon actually…kind of fascinates me, in a way I strongly suspect JKR didn’t intend him to. He shouts and screams a lot, but we’ve never (as far as I remember) seen him be violent, and I think if anyone ever laid hands on Petunia they’d wind up in the hospital. He seems like part of the Daily Mail/Mary Whitehouse subset of Brits who quietly vote BNP (famously racist political party) and bemoan All Those People Coming Here Taking Our Jobs…but yet Kingsley is the only wizard he has anything remotely approaching respect for. He hates anything ‘abnormal’…but he still married Petunia with her ties to a world that confused and scared him. He’s…holy cow, he’s Umbridge! Except that he, unlike her, has people he loves and who love him back… Dudley being named for his ‘dud’ quality hurt and fit in all the best ways. I reckon Petunia called him that as an open defiance against James. “You think my son is a dud? Worthless? I’ll show you what my son can do.” I also really appreciate having the Muggle/Wizard divide illustrated so well. The Wizarding World does hold itself above and apart from Muggles to such an extent that the lines connecting them can’t always be seen. I liked Lily’s struggle to convince James that Muggles have power – are actually capable of things, believe it or not – and his apparent inability (as someone born and raised in the Wizarding World) to see them as even being close to equals. The divide between the Muggle and Wizarding worlds fascinates me. It provides such very good fanfic fodder, just because it’s never really explored in the books. And it’s…well, it’s not very nice at all when you get down to it. Ron, for example, thinks it’s okay to randomly wipe a Muggle’s mind just so he can pass his driving test. (This line actually inspired a whole fic…it’s such a tiny throwaway line, but it says so much.) And Ron’s one of the heroes! And then there’s all the wizards in GOF, randomly wiping minds when they feel it’s convinent…ooh, it makes me mad. Thank you SO MUCH for this review! It’s absolutely lovely. :D
July 5, 2012 @ 11:36 am
This is a good, thoughtful behind-the-scenes look at Lily and Petunia as adults. I liked the way nothing was simple, right to the end. And I really liked your Petunia and Lily, the way they both seem so hurt by the way their relationship has played out, always almost-but-not-quite ready to give up on each other.
July 5, 2012 @ 5:55 pm
Aww thank you! According to JKR, Petunia and Lily met (I think?) once more after Dudley was born, at Lily and James’s wedding. Wonder how that went…
July 5, 2012 @ 12:42 pm
WOW, I liked this so much! I actually gasped when poor Vernon threw aside his pride to beg for help from Lily and James. And I thought Lily was being pulled in different directions, and felt totally sorry for her — but then even she had a bit of an agenda in offering help to Petunia. And if Dudley started out with all these medical risks, it’s easy to see how his parents might have overly doted upon him. Great take on all of them!
July 5, 2012 @ 6:01 pm
Thank you! :D Yeah…add Dudley’s health problems, the fact that he was an only child, and the fact that he wasn’t a ‘freak’ together and that would explain why the Dursleys indulged him so much. Maybe they also spoiled him in comparison to Harry because they thought something like, “You’re a wizard, you already have all the advantages in life, so shut up and allow us to give our son even half of what you’re going to end up having.” Which isn’t a good thing, not remotely (heck, it’s still child abuse) but…I guess it’s sort of understandable? Damn, the Dursleys are fascinating!
July 5, 2012 @ 3:36 pm
This gives such a thoughtful picture of the choices faced by the Potters and Dursleys right at the beginning. The links and divisions between the two worlds do come across well. And the spectre of Voldemort and the prophecy in the background is well worked out – raising the question of whether Dumbledore (who was far too certain about Harry being the Chosen One) might have been wrong right from the beginning. A good read.
July 5, 2012 @ 6:02 pm
Thank you very much. :D Oh, the possibilities. A Chosen Dudley would be…interesting…very much so.
July 5, 2012 @ 4:11 pm
So nicely done, with its rethinking of canon–and much more interesting, methinks! I love the relationships you’ve built between the characters, and I especially love that Vernon isn’t quite the cookie-cutter arse he’s made out to be elsewhere. And James is a bit of a prat, isn’t he? Thanks for the lovely story.
July 5, 2012 @ 6:04 pm
Thank you! :D I do think James was a good man and a good father. But he was (like most of the Wizarding World) basically a monster when it came to Muggles. The whole society treats them like pets, or worse, animals. :( You are very welcome. :D
July 6, 2012 @ 3:37 am
I really love this. You don’t waste a word, but everything flows smoothly and all the characters seem really sketched out. Lovely :D
July 7, 2012 @ 8:58 pm
Aw, thank you very much. :D
July 6, 2012 @ 10:13 am
I love it! More! More!
July 7, 2012 @ 8:58 pm
Thank you! :D
July 7, 2012 @ 4:43 pm
Whoa, amazing premise. Great job!
July 7, 2012 @ 8:58 pm
Thanks! :D
July 7, 2012 @ 8:51 pm
Absolutely beautiful. If I weren’t on a tablet, I would rave in depth.
July 7, 2012 @ 8:58 pm
Aw, thank you very much. :D
July 12, 2012 @ 4:34 pm
I loved this!
July 13, 2012 @ 9:58 pm
Thank you! :D
July 17, 2012 @ 12:15 am
i love it the boy who lived….. and i explains the dursleys hate for magic
July 17, 2012 @ 12:16 am
btw please friend me i love your stories and i hope you will love mine btw mine are only opened to friends
July 18, 2012 @ 1:50 pm
Thank you. :D
July 19, 2012 @ 5:28 pm
well its really cool i liked it you should right more!!! :D = D